Temo Van Tongeren Wants to Give Away His House

Temo Van Tongeren (pictured above) and Nicoline Van Cann are Waiheke people currently attracting a lot of attention. Motivated by a desire to fund  unspecified projects that "aim to create a better life for us all, now and in the future", they've designed an on-line competition with their house and car as the prize. Temo and Nicoline appeared on Island Life to answer questions about their motivation, what they will they do with the money they raise, whether they are legit, and the legality of the scheme? The pair are sincere but there are strict rules about running any gambling activity or prize competition and what the funds raised can be used for and it's not clear that this scheme meets those criteria. The competition website is http://www.vt-trust.com and you can read more about the rules for fund-raising competitions in the Ministry of Internal Affairs Rules for Running a Gambling Activity and the Authorised Purpose Guidelines, which set out what the money can be spent on.

UPDATE 15 Aug: Waiheke Radio has sought clarification from the Department of Internal Affairs about any regulations that may impact on the VT-Trust competition. The Department has notified us that they could not answer our questions as are investigating this matter.


Download podcast

 

House comps

I've done a bit of research about this and it looks like this type of project is picking up - 'selling' your house by running a competition.

Lots in the UK from what I can see: http://win-house.co.uk/blog/running-your-own-competition/4-costs-of-runn....

Obviously things are different over here in terms of costs to sell your home but looks like the principle is the same? I do think the idea of raising awareness for a good cause through a comp makes sense, good luck to this couple, I'll be watching this closely.

Posted by Visitor (not verified) on Mon, 16/08/2010 - 00:48
Good luck Temo

Hey I think the host was a little harsh on the couple there. Granted, the questions were legitimate and some of the answers somewhat unsatisfactory, but the overall undermining tone of the the interview went beyond what might be warranted by healthy skepticism.

Clearly, Temo's ideas need more definition. The difficulty is not to be underestimated however. What constitues a social businesses or social enterprise is a question that society is struggling to answer..What is clear however, is that there is growing interest in how such organisations might help us achieve both social and private gains, and impove upon existing models of delivery.

So, yes he doesn't quite know yet how to go about everything and situate his initiative in an orhtodox 'private sector - public sector' spectrum, but at the same time neither do you in all likelihood, and importantly, neither do a lot of other people working on the matter. So in short, maybe cut the guy some slack?

So I wish Temo and his wife the best of luck! I'm not personally enthralled by the game concept, but then that's a different matter. I hope you get everything sorted out, and if want to add your win a house competition to my website, feel free to get in touch.

 

Posted by Eyes at Win a House Watch (not verified) on Tue, 17/08/2010 - 02:08
Too Harsh?

Thanks for the feedback on the interview. I considered carefully what approach to take in this interview. In the end I felt the fact that Temo is asking people to give him money, and that he has said this is for enviromental projects, warranted a firm line of questioning. Temo has made a public pledge to be transparent, this justifies asking questions about the specific purposes the funds will be used for when this information doesn't appear on the website. If people enter this competition in good will, but there is a danger of it folding because it doesn't comply with the law they deserve to know this too. Community radio sometimes has to strike a balance between supporting local initiatives and applying media scrutiny. We appreciate feedback on how you think we are doing with this.

Posted by Chris on Tue, 17/08/2010 - 10:07
The social aspect

My feeling is that while Temo is probably sincere in his desire one would expect that if you are asking for peoples money for a social enterprise of the nature he is claiming (and he is hoping to raise nearly $600,000 NZ excess from this) then you'd have a much clearer idea of what you were going to fund from the proceeds and be able to articulate that cause with some finesse. His half-baked notion of some Finnish CO2 collection device just didn't cut it for me and made me suspicious that this is really just a way to sell a house in a difficult market and make a profit at the same time. For all the talk of transparency on the website and Facebook page this just doesn't add up. I'd have imagined that this would have been a priority, but it clearly isn't. For all his love of Waiheke why not identify some local causes as well; Waiheke is currently drafting a desire to become a UNESCO recognized biosphere region which could have lasting environmental gains for this island, this would have been an easy project for some benevolent funding. I think he has focused too much on the game and the prize itself rather than the outcomes and it makes me wary that he's just a real-estate agent in sheeps clothing.

Posted by Countrymike on Tue, 17/08/2010 - 10:16
Post new comment
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and not a cursed spammer.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters (without spaces) shown in the image.